Altrincham 1–3 Southend United: Cardwell turns a shaky start into a winning one

Eight minutes in, and already chasing the game

We actually had an early chance. Cardwell picked off a loose pass from Matty Kosylo, Leon Chambers-Parillon delivered from the left and Charley Kendall headed over. It was the sort of opening you want on the first afternoon of a new campaign: win the ball high up, get it into the box and give the home defence something to think about.

Unfortunately, Altrincham did rather more with their first proper opening. Aidan Barlow got his shot away, Joe Duncan saved it, and Tom Crawford was there to turn home the rebound from a tight angle in the eighth minute. It happened quickly, and it was all too easy from Southend’s point of view. The home captain was alert, we weren’t quite alert enough, and that was that.

I had hoped the new-look side would start on the front foot. Instead, we were asking them to show something else entirely: how they respond when the afternoon immediately goes against them. The Robins, who had beaten us on this ground in March, were in no hurry to hand the initiative back.

Liam Humbles caused problems with his movement, Crawford was influential and there were stretches when we couldn’t string enough purposeful possession together. A midfield containing Darren Oldaker and Anthony Hartigan ought to give us control, but control isn’t something you get simply by putting two good footballers on the teamsheet. There has to be an understanding with the players around them, and at times that wasn’t there yet.

Kyle McAdam lifted a chance over the bar, but that was not enough to make me feel we had really got hold of the match. For a spell it was Altrincham who looked more settled, more certain about what they wanted to do. They weren’t playing like a side impressed by Southend’s summer recruitment. Why would they?

Chambers-Parillon finds an answer

When you’re not playing particularly well, sometimes you need somebody to take responsibility rather than wait for the perfect team move. Chambers-Parillon did exactly that in the 37th minute.

He took possession on the left, cut inside Crawford and hit a low effort beyond Owen Evans at his near post. No elaborate build-up, no endless extra pass. A bit of conviction and a finish that changed the mood of the afternoon. From where we had been after twenty minutes, going in level suddenly looked a very good outcome.

I liked that he was willing to make something happen. It’s one thing to have talented wide players; it’s another for them to get at opponents and give defenders a decision to make. Chambers-Parillon did that and was rewarded. We are going to need more of it this season, especially against teams who sit in and invite us to pass the ball around in front of them.

But there is no point pretending the equaliser solved everything. Altrincham still had openings before the break. Crawford saw an effort deflected narrowly wide and then struck from distance, forcing Duncan into a fine full-stretch save. That was a big moment. If the home side had gone back in front just before half-time, we might have been looking at a very different afternoon.

Duncan came to Southend with Collin Andeng-Ndi’s departure still fresh in our minds. That is a tough position for any new goalkeeper to walk into. I certainly wasn’t going to judge him on one rebound in the eighth minute, and his later save underlined why. He kept us on terms when we needed him to.

At the interval it was Altrincham 1–1 Southend United. On balance, I was relieved rather than satisfied. We had shown enough attacking quality to get back into it, but there was plenty to talk about in the dressing room.

Cardwell makes the keeper’s mistake count

Harry Cardwell’s contribution to Southend’s second goal is exactly the sort of thing that can go missing if you only look at who scored. The goal belongs to Oli Coker, and rightly so. But Cardwell created the whole opportunity by refusing to give up on a ball that a less determined striker might have left alone.

In the 53rd minute, Altrincham goalkeeper Evans took too long over his clearance. Cardwell went after him, blocked it, stayed with the loose ball and then had the presence of mind to backheel into Coker’s path. With the goalkeeper out of position, Oli put the ball into an empty net.

One moment of hesitation by Evans, one moment of hunger from our centre-forward, and suddenly Southend were 2–1 up. It’s easy to describe that as a gift from the opposition. It was a mistake, certainly, but mistakes don’t turn into goals unless somebody is ready to force and punish them. Cardwell earned the chance for Coker.

I was delighted for Oli as well. He has grown up with this club and now finds himself captaining a reshaped Southend side. Scoring in the first league game of a new era will do him no harm at all. The finish was straightforward once the work had been done, but he still had to be in the right place and keep his head. He did both.

We were in front without having dominated, which is something of a novelty in itself. The important question was whether we could build on it or spend the next half-hour hanging on.

Two substitutions that changed the feel of it

Dyer made his first changes in the 56th minute. Sahid Kamara replaced Hartigan, while Ryan Colclough came on for Kendall. I thought those were telling substitutions. Southend needed another dimension to their attacks, and the two of them gave us precisely that.

Kamara’s running on the right made Altrincham retreat and gave Vontae Daley-Campbell someone to combine with. Colclough was prepared to get on the ball and go at people, testing Evans and asking awkward questions of a defence that had looked reasonably comfortable in the first half. It wasn’t just about fresh legs. It changed where the match was being played and how the home side had to defend.

There was still a moment of real anxiety when a bouncing ball struck Daley-Campbell’s arm in the penalty area and Altrincham appealed for a spot-kick. Referee Zac Kennard-Kettle waved play on. You can imagine the arguments if that decision had gone the other way. From our perspective it was a reprieve, and I would be daft to claim there was nothing at all to worry about.

Matty Kosylo then had two bookings in quick succession, the second in the 70th minute after a challenge on Colclough near halfway. Off he went, leaving the hosts with ten men. It helped us, of course it did. But we were already ahead when the red card arrived, and that matters. The comeback was not something handed to Southend by a sending-off.

With an extra player we had opportunities to finish it sooner. Evans saved from Coker and blocked Kamara’s follow-up before the loose ball came off Chambers-Parillon and went over. Daley-Campbell also forced a save, the goalkeeper tipping his effort away. That was the spell when we should have made the afternoon comfortable. Instead, the cushion was still only one goal and I was still watching the clock.

Colclough, Kamara, Cardwell: job done

The third goal, in the 85th minute, was a lovely example of three players doing the right thing at the right time. Colclough spotted a heavy touch from Charlie Kirk and took advantage, switching the ball across to Kamara. The substitute drove on, worked past a challenge and slipped Cardwell in. Harry did the rest, finishing into the far corner.

It was the reward Cardwell deserved for an afternoon of work. He had set up the second by chasing a lost cause and scored the third by making the right run and finishing decisively. If you’re looking for a centre-forward’s contribution, there’s a pretty convincing example. He doesn’t need to score twenty-yard screamers every week. Do the difficult, unglamorous things and get on the end of good chances. That will do nicely.

Kamara deserves his share of the credit. There is a difference between running quickly and running with a purpose, and the pass for Cardwell showed the latter. Colclough’s interception and switch were equally important. The substitutes didn’t merely help see out the win; they made it safe.

At 3–1, the 801 away supporters could finally enjoy the last few minutes without checking the clock every thirty seconds. Considering how the match had started, that felt like quite a turnaround. Full-time brought the three points and Dyer’s first competitive victory as Southend manager.

Who caught the eye, and what still needs work?

Harry Cardwell is my standout. It isn’t only the goal. The press on Evans, the backheel for Oli Coker and his willingness to keep running made a tangible difference to the result. A forward who can force an error and then finish a move offers far more than somebody who simply waits in the area.

Leon Chambers-Parillon changed the match when we badly needed a spark. He was positive, backed himself and found the equaliser. That is what I want to see from our attacking players: have a go when the opportunity is there.

Joe Duncan had an awkward afternoon to navigate. He could do little to prevent Crawford reaching the rebound for the opener, but the save before half-time was crucial. New goalkeepers need moments that build confidence, and that was one.

Oli Coker was alive to Cardwell’s hard work and calmly accepted the chance. Scoring is always welcome; scoring when your side needs to get ahead is better still. It was a captain’s contribution even if the finish itself looked simple.

Sahid Kamara and Ryan Colclough deserve to be mentioned together. Their arrival gave us pace, directness and a better attacking balance. If Dyer wanted proof that he has options beyond his starting eleven, he got some here.

Defensively, though, there is still work to do. Humbles found room to cause trouble, Crawford looked capable of hurting us more than once, and at times our midfield and back line looked too easy to play between. We cannot rely on chasing matches every Saturday. Nor will every opponent finish with ten men.

I also want us to find our rhythm earlier. The players will need time to understand one another, and I accept that. But a slow start can cost points against a side that knows how to protect a lead. One good result should give us confidence, not convince us every problem has disappeared.

Match details